| Platinum | The Goat and Vine |
| Gold | Times Square Pizzaria |
| Silver | Campini's Italian Deli |
| Bronze | Rosati's Pizza |
| Top Pick | Blaze Pizza |
| Top Pick | Filippi's Pizza Grotto Temecula |
| Top Pick | Spuntino Pizzeria |
| Top Pick | Stadium Pizza |
| Top Pick | Upper East Slice |
| Top Pick | Vail Pizzeria |